Coaching and Mentoring: Which do I need?

Achieving Goals, Career Enrichment, Leadership Coaching, Mindset & Mindfulness
05/15/23 - Ama La Vida
woman looking at computer screen and waving

When it comes to personal and professional development, coaching and mentoring are two of the most common approaches to help individuals reach their goals. However, while these terms are often used interchangeably, there are significant differences between coaching and mentoring that make them better suited for certain situations. Whether you’re a high-potential employee looking to advance in your career, an organization seeking to develop your employees, or simply an individual looking to grow personally and professionally, understanding the differences between coaching and mentoring can help you choose the approach that’s right for you. In this article, we’ll explore the key differences between coaching and mentoring, and how each can benefit your development goals.

How are coaching and mentoring different?

While these two terms are often used interchangeably, there are distinct differences between them. Coaching is a collaborative relationship with a certified coach who is trained to help you achieve your goals efficiently and effectively.

On the other hand, mentoring is a relationship where a seasoned individual shares their personal experience to guide and advise you on your career journey. Understanding the differences between coaching and mentoring can help you determine which approach is best for your needs.

Let’s take a closer look at the key differences between the two approaches.

What is a mentor?


Photo by Mimi Thian on Unsplash

A mentor is someone who has experience in a specific area and is willing to share that experience with others. Mentors are typically individuals who have achieved success in their careers and are now seeking to give back by helping others reach their potential. They can be a valuable resource for those looking to gain insight into a particular industry or role. The goal of a mentoring relationship is to help the mentee gain skills, knowledge, and confidence, and to provide guidance and support in achieving their personal and professional goals.

What is the mentor and mentee relationship?

A mentor and mentee relationship is a mutually beneficial and development-focused relationship between two individuals where a more experienced person (the mentor) provides guidance, support, knowledge transfer, and advice to someone with less experience (the mentee). The mentor’s role is to share their experience with the mentee, to help them develop specific skills, and achieve their personal and professional goals.

The mentee, in turn, benefits from the mentor’s guidance, feedback, and support, gaining insights and perspectives that can help them grow and succeed in their careers and personal lives. This can be a formal or informal arrangement and can last for a specific period or continue over a longer period, depending on the goals and needs of both parties.

While organizations may establish a mentorship program for their high-potential employees to increase employee engagement and knowledge transfer, it is also possible to find mentors through your own personal and professional network.

How can mentoring help your career?

Working with a mentor can also provide a valuable networking opportunity. Through it, mentees can gain access to their mentor’s professional network and senior level executives, which can lead to new opportunities and connections. It also can provide mentees with a sense of belonging and support through the mentoring relationship itself, as well as the connections within the industry. This can be especially helpful for individuals who are new to a particular field or who are looking to make a career change.

A business mentor can also provide mentees with a wealth of knowledge and experience that can help them navigate the often complex and challenging world of work. Mentors often act as role models by sharing their own experiences. They can also help mentees develop new skills and perspectives, and provide them with valuable insights into the industry or the organization’s goals to ensure that mentees are moving their projects or careers in the right direction.

In addition, having a mentor can help boost a mentee’s confidence and sense of self-worth. Just having someone who believes in them and their abilities can make a significant difference in the way someone feels about their current position and skill level. This can be particularly valuable for individuals who are just starting out in a new career, or who are feeling unsure about their current path. Not only can a mentor provide encouragement, praise, and recognition for your achievements, but they can also provide you with constructive feedback and guidance on how to improve your skills, knowledge, and performance in your field. This feedback can help you identify your strengths and weaknesses, as well as areas for improvement, which can boost your confidence in your abilities.

It’s also worth noting that working with a mentor is not always a one-way street. Mentors can also learn from their mentees by gaining fresh perspectives and new ideas! Whether the pair are in complementary roles or in the more traditional junior-senior partnership, the partnership can and should be mutually beneficial. Ultimately, mentorship can be a rewarding experience for both parties, providing valuable learning, growth, and connection.

As you are building your professional network, it’s a good idea to keep your mind open to building connections with multiple mentors, as each one will bring their own specific skills and expertise.

What is the role of the mentee?

To get the most out of working with a mentor, the mentee is responsible for seeking advice, asking questions, and being open to feedback and suggestions. They should also come prepared with specific goals and objectives they want to achieve, and work collaboratively with their mentor to identify strategies to reach those goals. A mentee who is engaged and committed to the process is more likely to experience success and personal growth through the relationship.

Communicate openly and honestly with your mentor, ask questions, and be receptive to feedback. Remember that mentorship is a two-way street, and both parties need to be invested for it to be successful.

Finally, showing gratitude and appreciation for your mentor’s time and effort can go a long way in building a strong and lasting relationship.

What is coaching?


Photo by Surface on Unsplash

According to the International Coaching Federation (the ICF), “Coaching is a collaborative partnership between a coach and a client in a thought-provoking and creative process that inspires the client to maximize their personal and professional potential. The coach works with the client to identify their goals, strengths, and areas for improvement, and supports them in creating actionable plans to achieve their desired outcomes. Coaching is a non-judgmental and confidential space for the client to explore their thoughts, feelings, and behaviors in order to gain clarity, self-awareness, and focus. The ultimate aim of coaching is to help clients bridge the gap between where they are currently and where they want to be, both personally and professionally.”

Another way of saying it, coaching is a process in which a trained professional helps individuals to identify their goals, develop a plan of action, and make progress towards achieving those goals. The coach provides support, encouragement, and accountability to help the individual overcome obstacles and stay on track.

What is a career coach?

A career coach is a professional who works with individuals to help them identify and achieve their career goals. Unlike mentors who provide guidance based on personal experience, coaches utilize their training and expertise in career development to provide clients with actionable steps to achieve their desired outcomes.

Career coaches can help with a variety of topics, such as:

  • Identifying paths for career growth and personal development and setting professional goals
  • Improving relationships with your coworkers, direct reports, and supervisors by building your interpersonal skills
  • Developing job search strategies, such as identifying criteria for your next role, building a resume, interview strategies, and offer negotiation
  • Building leadership skills and improving your effectiveness with your team
  • Enhancing networking skills and building your personal brand

They can work with clients at any stage of their career, whether it’s someone just starting out, mid-career, or approaching retirement. The main focus of a career coach is to help clients develop the skills and knowledge they need to reach their full potential in their chosen career path.


Photo by LinkedIn Sales Solutions on Unsplash

How do coaching sessions work?

Coaching sessions are typically one-on-one meetings between the coach and the client, where the coach helps the client identify their goals, develop an action plan, and make progress towards achieving those goals.

The specifics of how a coach leads sessions can vary depending on the coach and the client, but generally, they involve a discussion of the client’s current situation, their goals and aspirations, and any obstacles or challenges that they are facing. The coach may ask probing questions to help the client gain clarity and perspective, provide feedback and direction, and offer accountability and support as the client works towards their goals.

At Ama La Vida, our coaching program also employs eCoaching content to support clients between sessions. These are online exercises that mimic the experience of one-on-one coaching conversations so that clients have time to reflect without the limit of a coaches time, and also help the coaching relationship move forward between sessions. The added benefit of these online exercises are the measurable results they also provide.

How can a coach help your career development?

Unlike mentors, a coach can help you grow in your career by guiding you through a journey of self-discovery and empowerment. By focusing on your personal vision and goals, an effective coach can help you craft a clear and inspiring picture of your future. This includes identifying areas where you may not be utilizing your strengths to their fullest potential or where you may be neglecting your personal boundaries.

Once you have a clear picture of what you want to achieve, a coach can help you align your vision with your current reality. Through practical exercises and expert support, you’ll learn how to make meaningful changes that will bring you closer to the career and life you envision for yourself. This includes developing self-awareness about your communication and operating style and learning how to set and achieve meaningful goals.

A coach can also help you be proactive in managing your career trajectory. This involves empowering you to expand your network and engage in ongoing growth and development to ensure your skill set never becomes stale. With the right processes in place, you’ll be able to keep a pulse on your environment and have an abundance of opportunities at any time.

Ultimately, a coach can help you become more self-aware, confident, and proactive in achieving your career goals. By working with a coach, you’ll develop invaluable skills that will keep your career on track and your options limitless.

The key difference between coaches and mentors, and why you need both

Mentoring and coaching are both valuable resources for growing and progressing professionally, but they serve different purposes. A coach is a professional who helps you identify and achieve your goals by providing insight and accountability. A certified coach will have expertise in coaching techniques designed to give you a unique perspective and to tap into your own best interest. Through their training program and additional experience, a coach will utilize specific coaching skills, like active listening and deep questioning, to help you take your own insights further.

On the other hand, a mentor is typically someone who has more experience and knowledge in a particular field or industry and can provide guidance based on their own background. They may offer advice on how to navigate challenges or provide insight into industry trends and best practices. Mentors can be great sources of inspiration and wisdom, but they may not have the same level of training or expertise in coaching techniques. That means that they can tell you what they’ve done or how they’d approach something, but may not be able to help you navigate your personal experiences or tap into your own strengths.

Both coaching and mentorship can be incredibly valuable for career development. Coaching focuses on helping you set goals, create a plan of action, and hold you accountable to your commitments. They can also provide objective feedback and help you identify blind spots. A mentor can offer insights into a specific industry or profession, provide guidance, and give advice on how to navigate challenging situations.

Ideally, you should seek out both coaching and mentorship to support your career development. A coach can help you identify and work towards your goals and optimize your own skills, while a mentor can offer advice and direction based on their own experiences. With the support of both a coach and a mentor, you’ll have a well-rounded perspective and be better equipped to navigate your career path.

When a coach is best for you

If you are feeling stuck or unfulfilled in your current career, a coach may be the best option for you. A coach can provide you with the guidance and support you need to identify your goals, explore your strengths and weaknesses, and develop a plan for achieving your objectives. If you are struggling with work-related stress, burnout, or a lack of motivation, a coach can help you find ways to manage your emotions and stay focused on your goals. Additionally, if you are facing a significant career transition, such as a promotion or a career change, a coach can provide you with the tools and strategies you need to navigate these changes successfully.

It’s important to note that coaching is not a one-size-fits-all solution. If you are looking for someone to provide you with specific industry knowledge or technical skills, a coach may not be the best fit. In these cases, a mentor or a subject matter expert may be a better option.

Ultimately, the decision to work with a coach should be based on your specific needs and goals. If you are looking for personal growth and development, and need guidance on how to achieve your career objectives, then working with a coach can be a highly effective way to reach your goals.

Here’s our guide to finding the right coach.

Ready to get started? Click here to find out how coaching can help you.

Related Articles

What are your professional goals? It’s a question that can make even the most seasoned professionals pause. Whether you’re just starting out or well into your career, setting professional goals is crucial. It’s about more than just climbing the corporate ladder. It’s worth taking the time to figure out your professional goals. This process is […]

Read More
woman looking at computer writing down notes in her journal

Let’s face it, no one ever teaches you how to navigate your career. At best, we get half-hearted questions like, “What do you want to be when you grow up?” and “Do you know what you’re going to do when you finish school?” From there, you can try to find a mentor or hope for […]

Read More
woman working and taking notes

Do you find yourself overwhelmed by the prospect of making a career decision? Have you ever felt afraid that the wrong choice might impact your immediate future, long-term happiness, financial stability, and overall lifestyle? If so, you’re not alone. These feelings are common symptoms of a condition known as career paralysis—a state of feeling stuck […]

Read More